Ten-year old Tammy refuses to wrap a Christmas present intended for her cousin, hoping to keep the doll for herself. Later, through a dream, she travels back to Bethlehem to witness a little stableboy's act of unselfish love when he gives the Christ child his pet lamb. Tammy then realizes how sharing presents with others is a way of sharing God's love at Christmastime.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Danielle BriseboisTammy | Tammy |
 Michael Anderson Jr.Father | Father |
 Darleen CarrMother | Mother |
 Dave MaddenRoman Centurion | Roman Centurion |
 William SchallertThe Innkeeper | The Innkeeper |
 Jerry HouserJoseph | Joseph |
 Steve FrankenVendor | Vendor |
 Frank CampanellaGaspar | Gaspar |
 Ross ElliottMan | Man |
 Sparky MarcusThe Stableboy | The Stableboy |
| JJane Alice BrandonMary | Mary |
| AAllan LuriePasserby | Passerby |