 Danielle PanabakerKatie Lapp | Katie Lapp |
 Sherry StringfieldLaura Mayfield-Bennett | Laura Mayfield-Bennett |
| SSarah MaineJessica | Jessica |
| WWillie StratfordTheodore | Theodore |
| JJason LoughlinBenjamin Lapp | Benjamin Lapp |
 Sandra Elise WilliamsRebecca Lapp | Rebecca Lapp |
 Bill Oberst Jr.Samuel Lapp | Samuel Lapp |
| WWyatt LanierJacob Beiler | Jacob Beiler |
 Burgess JenkinsBishop John Beiler | Bishop John Beiler |
| DDalton ParrishHickory John Beiler | Hickory John Beiler |
| DDavid ToppDaniel Fisher | Daniel Fisher |
 Richard FullertonEphram Yoder | Ephram Yoder |
 Nancy SaundersElla Mae Zook | Ella Mae Zook |
 Rachel St. GelaisBenjamin's Daughter | Benjamin's Daughter |
 Jana AllenAmanda | Amanda |
| SSarah E. ChambersMary Stoltzfus | Mary Stoltzfus |
| JJimmy HagerPreacher Yoder | Preacher Yoder |
| DDavid ForresterAmish Elder | Amish Elder |
 Robert C. TreveilerSurgeon | Surgeon |
| SStephen West-RogersTrauma Nurse | Trauma Nurse |
| LLee FreemanNurse Rosie | Nurse Rosie |
 Alexa YeamesYoung Laura | Young Laura |
| TTim HoltDylan Bennett | Dylan Bennett |
| MMichele LeeStore Clerk | Store Clerk |
 Lindsey MoserNurse (uncredited) | Nurse (uncredited) |
| SScott HelmAmish Man | Amish Man |
| JJacob AllenYoung Amish Bachelor (Uncredited) | Young Amish Bachelor (Uncredited) |
| KKirk BassYoung Samuel (Uncredited) | Young Samuel (Uncredited) |
| LLeanne BernardBus Patron (Uncredited) | Bus Patron (Uncredited) |
| RRandy BernardBus Patron (Uncredited) | Bus Patron (Uncredited) |
