 Don KnottsDr. Jesse W. Heywood | Dr. Jesse W. Heywood |
 Barbara RhoadesPenelope 'Bad Penny' Cushings | Penelope 'Bad Penny' Cushings |
 Jackie CooganMatthew Basch | Matthew Basch |
 Ruth McDevittMrs. Olive Heywood | Mrs. Olive Heywood |
 Frank McGrathMr. Remington | Mr. Remington |
 Terry WilsonWelsh | Welsh |
 Carl BallantineAbel Swanson | Abel Swanson |
 Pat MoritaWong | Wong |
 Robert YuroArnold the Kid | Arnold the Kid |
 Herb VolandDr. Friedlander | Dr. Friedlander |
 Fay DeWittViolet | Violet |
 Dub TaylorPop Cushings | Pop Cushings |
 Hope SummersCelia | Celia |
 Dick WilsonBlack Eagle (Indian chief) | Black Eagle (Indian chief) |
 Don 'Red' BarryRev. Zachary Gant | Rev. Zachary Gant |
 Vaughn TaylorRev. Longbaugh | Rev. Longbaugh |
 Ed PeckSheriff | Sheriff |
 Edward FaulknerMarshal Sam Huggins | Marshal Sam Huggins |
 Arthur SpaceSheriff Tolliver | Sheriff Tolliver |
 Greg MullaveyPhelps - Dental Student | Phelps - Dental Student |
 Fred AldrichPasserby (uncredited) | Passerby (uncredited) |
 E.J. AndréWill Banks | Will Banks |
 John AnistonIndian (uncredited) | Indian (uncredited) |
 Argentina BrunettiSquaw (uncredited) | Squaw (uncredited) |
 Claudia BryarMrs. Remington | Mrs. Remington |
 Paul BryarMan at Bar (uncredited) | Man at Bar (uncredited) |
 Noble 'Kid' ChissellTownsman (uncredited) | Townsman (uncredited) |
 William ChristopherHotel Manager (uncredited) | Hotel Manager (uncredited) |
 Frank Coghlan Jr.Man at Bar (uncredited) | Man at Bar (uncredited) |
 Warde DonovanTownsman (uncredited) | Townsman (uncredited) |
