Katie Mayfield is now the mistress of Mayfield Manor. In her new world she finds herself torn between two worlds and grieves for her plain Amish life. Does Katie choose her new life or the simple heritage she left behind?
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Katie LeclercKatie Lapp / Katherine Mayfield | Katie Lapp / Katherine Mayfield |
 Jacob BlairDaniel Fisher | Daniel Fisher |
 Chad ConnellJustin Wirth | Justin Wirth |
 Christopher RosamondRichard Davies | Richard Davies |
 Chantal PerronWedding Planner Rhonda | Wedding Planner Rhonda |
 Valerie PlancheRosie Taylor | Rosie Taylor |
 Rohan CampbellWillie | Willie |
 Barb MitchellMrs. Wirth | Mrs. Wirth |
 Christian GoutsisRex Bryant | Rex Bryant |
 Gerrick WinstonSelig | Selig |
| AAlex Fellowes SmithTugg | Tugg |
 Kevin RotherySamuel Lapp | Samuel Lapp |
 Vanessa HolmesRebecca Lapp | Rebecca Lapp |
| BBrian GromoffFulton | Fulton |
 Orin McCuskerAustin | Austin |
| JJames D. HopkinPreacher Yoder | Preacher Yoder |