Ben and Ashley come together 20 years after the murder of their parents to determine the cause of their parents' death. Ashley is troubled by the idea that the thing that took her parents' lives may not be finished with her family.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Rachel MelvinNicole | Nicole |
 Shenae Grimes-BeechAshley | Ashley |
 Izabella MikoCassie | Cassie |
 Stephen BrodieBen | Ben |
 Joe MullenJacob Murphy | Jacob Murphy |
 Joe NuñezJeremy | Jeremy |
 Joe CiprianoYoung Ben | Young Ben |
 Joey BicicchiAndrew | Andrew |
| AAlexa NasatirYoung Ashley | Young Ashley |