 Lon ChaneyErik, The Phantom | Erik, The Phantom |
 Norman KerryVicomte Raoul de Chagny | Vicomte Raoul de Chagny |
 Mary PhilbinChristine Daaé | Christine Daaé |
 Arthur Edmund CareweLedoux | Ledoux |
 Gibson GowlandSimon Buquet | Simon Buquet |
 Snitz EdwardsFlorine Papillon | Florine Papillon |
 John St. PolisComte Philip de Chagny | Comte Philip de Chagny |
 Virginia PearsonCarlotta | Carlotta |
 Olive Ann AlcornLa Sorelli (uncredited) | La Sorelli (uncredited) |
| BBetty Van AllenBallerina (uncredited) | Ballerina (uncredited) |
| BBetty ArthurBallet Dancer (uncredited) | Ballet Dancer (uncredited) |
 Joseph BelmontStage Manager (uncredited) | Stage Manager (uncredited) |
| AAlexander BevaniMephistopheles (uncredited) | Mephistopheles (uncredited) |
| EEarl Gordon BostwickMinor Role (uncredited) | Minor Role (uncredited) |
 Ethel BroadhurstFrightened Ballerina (uncredited) | Frightened Ballerina (uncredited) |
| EEdward CecilFaust (uncredited) | Faust (uncredited) |
 Ruth CliffordBallerina (uncredited) | Ballerina (uncredited) |
 Chester ConklinOrderly (uncredited) | Orderly (uncredited) |
| RRoy CoulsonThe Jester (uncredited) | The Jester (uncredited) |
 Bruce CovingtonM. Moncharmin (uncredited) | M. Moncharmin (uncredited) |
 Ward CraneCount Ruboff (uncredited) | Count Ruboff (uncredited) |
 George DavisGuard at Christine's Door (uncredited) | Guard at Christine's Door (uncredited) |
| MMadame FiorenzaMme. Giry - Keeper of the Box (uncredited) | Mme. Giry - Keeper of the Box (uncredited) |
| AAlan GeorgeUndetermined Secondary Role (uncredited) | Undetermined Secondary Role (uncredited) |
 Cesare GravinaManager (uncredited) | Manager (uncredited) |
 William HumphreyM. Debienne (uncredited) | M. Debienne (uncredited) |
 Carla LaemmlePrima Ballerina (uncredited) | Prima Ballerina (uncredited) |
| GGrace MarvinMartha (uncredited) | Martha (uncredited) |
 John MiljanValentin (uncredited) | Valentin (uncredited) |
| EEdith MurgatroydMama Valerius (uncredited) | Mama Valerius (uncredited) |
