Holly is tired of moving every time her mom Jean breaks up with yet another second-rate guy. To distract her mother from her latest bad choice, Holly conceives the perfect plan for the perfect man, an imaginary secret admirer who will romance Jean and boost her self-esteem.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Hilary DuffHolly Hamilton | Holly Hamilton |
 Heather LocklearJean Hamilton | Jean Hamilton |
 Chris NothBen Cooper | Ben Cooper |
 Mike O'MalleyLenny Horton | Lenny Horton |
 Ben FeldmanAdam Forrest | Adam Forrest |
 Vanessa LengiesAmy Pearl | Amy Pearl |
 Caroline RheaGloria | Gloria |
 Kym WhitleyDolores | Dolores |
 Aria WallaceZoe Hamilton | Zoe Hamilton |
 Michelle NoldenAmber | Amber |
 Carson KressleyLance | Lance |
 Curtis FletcherWedding Usher | Wedding Usher |
 Maggie CastleWichita Girl | Wichita Girl |
 James McGowanJean's Suitor | Jean's Suitor |
 Gerry MendicinoMarket Co-Worker | Market Co-Worker |
 Philip AkinEnglish Teacher | English Teacher |
 Jeff LumbyDr. Fitch | Dr. Fitch |
 Monique MojicaPrincipal Campbell | Principal Campbell |
 Marvin KayeConstruction Worker | Construction Worker |
| EEldridge HyndmanConstruction Worker | Construction Worker |
 Jung-Yul KimConstruction Worker | Construction Worker |
 Martin DoyleCake Contest MC | Cake Contest MC |