| DDoug HendersonNada | Nada |
| SSelina FlanschaThe Caller | The Caller |
| RRosaria ErasoCatalina (segment "The Backpage") | Catalina (segment "The Backpage") |
| NNina DonnellyScarlet (segment "Scarlet") | Scarlet (segment "Scarlet") |
| CCody EvansHunter (segment "Sorry for the Blood") | Hunter (segment "Sorry for the Blood") |
 Adam MichaelsVampire (segment "Sorry for the Blood") | Vampire (segment "Sorry for the Blood") |
| BBrendan KrickPaul (segment "The Backpage") | Paul (segment "The Backpage") |
 Greg YoungRobert (segment "Scarlet") | Robert (segment "Scarlet") |
| RRobert Hugh StarrOfficer Truman (segment "Indictment") | Officer Truman (segment "Indictment") |
| HHarley CubberleyDenice (segment "Scarlet") | Denice (segment "Scarlet") |
| AAndrew AdamsThe Stranger (segment "Indictment") | The Stranger (segment "Indictment") |
| JJames Stephen WalshCraig (segment "Scarlet") | Craig (segment "Scarlet") |
| EEm WhitworthCasey (segment "The Backpage") | Casey (segment "The Backpage") |
| NNick SomersOfficer Blake (segment "Indictment") | Officer Blake (segment "Indictment") |
| SShane RhoadesCathedral Thug (segment "Sorry for the Blood") | Cathedral Thug (segment "Sorry for the Blood") |
| DDerrick ScottNico (segment "Indictment") | Nico (segment "Indictment") |
