A girl and her friends find a game in the attic that summons a creature known as The Midnight Man, who uses their worst fears against them.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Gabrielle HaughAlex Luster | Alex Luster |
| GGrayson GabrielMiles | Miles |
 Lin ShayeAnna | Anna |
 Robert EnglundDr. Goodberry | Dr. Goodberry |
 Em HaineKelly | Kelly |
 Louise LintonAnnie Luster | Annie Luster |
 Abigail PniowskyYoung Kelly | Young Kelly |
 Michael SirowAlan | Alan |
 Summer H. HowellAnna | Anna |
| LLuca VillacisJaden | Jaden |
 Kyle StrautsThe Midnight Man | The Midnight Man |
 Logan CreranDr. Harding (10 yrs) | Dr. Harding (10 yrs) |
| KKeenan LehmannMax | Max |
 Callie LaneYoung Alex | Young Alex |
| MMeredith RoseMary | Mary |
| WWilliam JordanBunny Man | Bunny Man |