A manicurist predicts that an unlucky-at-love lawyer will meet the love of her life and that he will be a Michael, so the attorney begins a series of dates with men with that name.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Larisa OleynikKatherine Bixby | Katherine Bixby |
 Laura BreckenridgeMarcie Schlossberg | Marcie Schlossberg |
 Shaun SiposMichael Breakstone | Michael Breakstone |
 Brant DaughertyTom Stanfield | Tom Stanfield |
 Ryan SypekRick Wychowski | Rick Wychowski |
 Beverly D'AngeloMillie Barnworth | Millie Barnworth |
 Elliott GouldMax Barnworth | Max Barnworth |
 Diego SerranoJustin | Justin |
 Jared Farid WardMichael Gelbart | Michael Gelbart |