 Tyrone PowerDon Diego Vega, aka Zorro | Don Diego Vega, aka Zorro |
 Linda DarnellLolita Quintero | Lolita Quintero |
 Basil RathboneCaptain Esteban Pasquale | Captain Esteban Pasquale |
 Gale SondergaardInez Quintero | Inez Quintero |
 Eugene PalletteFriar Felipe | Friar Felipe |
 J. Edward BrombergDon Luis B. Quintero | Don Luis B. Quintero |
 Montagu LoveDon Alejandro Vega | Don Alejandro Vega |
 Janet BeecherSenora Isabella Vega | Senora Isabella Vega |
 George RegasSergeant Gonzales | Sergeant Gonzales |
 Chris-Pin MartinTurnkey | Turnkey |
 Robert LoweryRodrigo | Rodrigo |
 Belle MitchellMaria | Maria |
 John BleiferPedro | Pedro |
 Frank PugliaProprietor | Proprietor |
 Pedro de CordobaDon Miguel | Don Miguel |
 Guy D'EnneryDon Jose | Don Jose |
 Eugene BordenOfficer of the Day (uncredited) | Officer of the Day (uncredited) |
 Stanley AndrewsCommanding Officer (uncredited) | Commanding Officer (uncredited) |
 Fortunio BonanovaSentry (uncredited) | Sentry (uncredited) |
 Ralph ByrdStudent / Officer (uncredited) | Student / Officer (uncredited) |
| RRobert CauterioManuel (uncredited) | Manuel (uncredited) |
| BBob CautieroGroom (uncredited) | Groom (uncredited) |
 Robert Conway(uncredited) | (uncredited) |
 Gino CorradoCaballero (uncredited) | Caballero (uncredited) |
| FFranco CorsaroOrderly (uncredited) | Orderly (uncredited) |
| AAndre CuyasServant (uncredited) | Servant (uncredited) |
 Jean Del ValSentry (uncredited) | Sentry (uncredited) |
| JJoseph DeVillardSentry (uncredited) | Sentry (uncredited) |
| AArt DupuisSoldier (uncredited) | Soldier (uncredited) |
 William EdmundsPeón Selling Cocks (uncredited) | Peón Selling Cocks (uncredited) |
