On a snowy night in 1963 Pennsylvania, a boarding school student goes missing in the woods. Her friends, a disgraced quarterback, a shunned ex-cop, and the headmaster's wife, agree to go search for her. As they do, they confront the lies, ghost stories, and demonization that their idyllic school was built on.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Devin DruidE.W. Noyes | E.W. Noyes |
 Quinn ShephardJean Fenny | Jean Fenny |
 Sam WaterstonHeadmaster Waldorf | Headmaster Waldorf |
 Marin IrelandLouise Roethke | Louise Roethke |
 Kevin CorriganSal Mancuso | Sal Mancuso |
 William Jackson HarperBuster Heath | Buster Heath |
 Jack KilmerHobey Delmore | Hobey Delmore |
 Jane AlexanderVivien Waldorf | Vivien Waldorf |
 Odessa YoungPaula Hayward | Paula Hayward |
 Gus BirneySuzie Duvall | Suzie Duvall |
 John VentimigliaCommissioner Milo | Commissioner Milo |
| JJessica CarlsonLenore Cunningham | Lenore Cunningham |
 Michael PanesDavid Katz | David Katz |
| JJay Jay WarrenGabe Lehane | Gabe Lehane |
 Rodrigo LoprestiDetective Lacey | Detective Lacey |
 Nana MensahEthel McRae | Ethel McRae |
 Zoran RadanovichRudy Bunin | Rudy Bunin |
 Lorrie OdomBonnie Butler | Bonnie Butler |
| CChristy EscobarIda Kent | Ida Kent |
 Steven MarcusDoctor Fancher | Doctor Fancher |
| MMichael PreziosiRobin Goodfellow | Robin Goodfellow |
| JJake SingerJimmy Damon | Jimmy Damon |
 Emily Cass McDonnellCoffee Baker | Coffee Baker |