Carrie Simpkins, a lady lawyer, arrives in a small western town and begins the practice of law. Pete, Jake and Jerry, three cowboys, fall in love with her, but do not progress. Smithers, the pioneer town lawyer happens by and sees the sign, "Carrie Simpkins, Lawyer," and decides to pay her a visit, which he does, and he also falls in love with her. Pete, Jake and Jerry all hit upon the same plan unknown to each other, which will help their chances with Carrie.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Tom MixPete | Pete |
 Eugenie FordeCarrie Simpkins | Carrie Simpkins |
 Ed BradySmithers (as E.J. Brady) | Smithers (as E.J. Brady) |