 Preston FosterMarcus | Marcus |
 Alan HaleBurbix | Burbix |
 Basil RathbonePontius Pilate | Pontius Pilate |
| JJohn WoodAdult Flavius | Adult Flavius |
 Louis CalhernPrefect Allus Martius | Prefect Allus Martius |
 David HoltFlavius as a Boy | Flavius as a Boy |
 Dorothy WilsonClodia | Clodia |
 Wyrley BirchLeaster | Leaster |
 Frank ConroyGaius Tanno (uncredited) | Gaius Tanno (uncredited) |
 William V. MongCleon the Slave Dealer (uncredited) | Cleon the Slave Dealer (uncredited) |
 Murray KinnellSimon (uncredited) | Simon (uncredited) |
 Henry KolkerWarder (uncredited) | Warder (uncredited) |
 Edward Van SloanCalvus (uncredited) | Calvus (uncredited) |
 Zeffie TilburyThe Wise Woman (uncredited) | The Wise Woman (uncredited) |
 John DavidsonPhoebus (uncredited) | Phoebus (uncredited) |
 Ward BondMurmex of Carthage, a Gladiator (uncredited) | Murmex of Carthage, a Gladiator (uncredited) |
 Edwin MaxwellThe Augur, a Pompeii Official (uncredited) | The Augur, a Pompeii Official (uncredited) |
 Warner RichmondCaptain of the Guard (uncredited) | Captain of the Guard (uncredited) |
 Jim ThorpeSpectator Tossing Coins (uncredited) | Spectator Tossing Coins (uncredited) |
| BBuster WilesGladiator (uncredited) | Gladiator (uncredited) |
| HHannah WilliamsCitizen of Pompeii (uncredited) | Citizen of Pompeii (uncredited) |
 Jason Robards Sr.Tax Gatherer (uncredited) | Tax Gatherer (uncredited) |
 John T. MurrayPilate's Servant (uncredited) | Pilate's Servant (uncredited) |
 Cliff LyonsOstorius - a Gladiator (uncredited) | Ostorius - a Gladiator (uncredited) |
 Paul KrugerOarsman (uncredited) | Oarsman (uncredited) |
 Jimmy DimeHeckling Gladiator (uncredited) | Heckling Gladiator (uncredited) |
 Douglas CosgroveGaius' Steward (uncredited) | Gaius' Steward (uncredited) |
| AArt FelixRider on Horseback (uncredited) | Rider on Horseback (uncredited) |
 Winston HiblerMarcellus (uncredited) | Marcellus (uncredited) |
| MMarc LoebellLucius (uncredited) | Lucius (uncredited) |
