| AAngelina HylerDr. Cantaway | Dr. Cantaway |
| JJohn KelleherRev. Fred Phelps | Rev. Fred Phelps |
| DDebbie ParryWaitress | Waitress |
| EEmily BoyerRomaine Patterson | Romaine Patterson |
| JJoshua TuckerMoises Kaufman / Dennis Shepard | Moises Kaufman / Dennis Shepard |
| LLevi HawkesGov. / Matt Mickleson | Gov. / Matt Mickleson |
| MMarlene CreaserEileen Engen | Eileen Engen |
| AAnden J LeoJonas Sloanaker | Jonas Sloanaker |
| BBrielle HawkesReggie Flutty | Reggie Flutty |
| CCalvin HallGreg Pierotti / Sgt. Hing | Greg Pierotti / Sgt. Hing |
| JJason BuiJon Peacock | Jon Peacock |
| LLarry HallDoug Law / Mormon Home Teacher | Doug Law / Mormon Home Teacher |
| MMaggie BarryCatherine Connolly | Catherine Connolly |
| MMary MoserZackie Salmon / Kerry Drake | Zackie Salmon / Kerry Drake |
| MMay WongSherry Aenenson / Sherry Johnson | Sherry Aenenson / Sherry Johnson |
| MMiguel TorresDoc O'Connor | Doc O'Connor |
| SShawn BettingerBaptist Minister | Baptist Minister |
| KKieran VuAaron McKinney | Aaron McKinney |
| EEmma LawrenceApril Silva | April Silva |
| LLauren OultonJen | Jen |
| JJonah Ladish-OrlichRussell Henderson & Bailiff | Russell Henderson & Bailiff |
| AAlly CastagnaZubadia Ula | Zubadia Ula |
| MMichael AllenFather Roger Schmidt | Father Roger Schmidt |
| BBob SandallRobert DuBois | Robert DuBois |
| TTopher ToddRulon Stacey | Rulon Stacey |
| KKen CalandraAndy Paris | Andy Paris |
| TTaylor StendaraBarbara Pitts | Barbara Pitts |
| MMickie WebbekingKristin Price | Kristin Price |
| KKaylyn YagerShannon | Shannon |
| AAllie HildeAmanda Gronich / Leigh Fondakowski | Amanda Gronich / Leigh Fondakowski |
