 Vanessa HudgensBrooke | Brooke |
 Josh WhitehouseSir Cole Christopher Frederick Lyons of Norwich | Sir Cole Christopher Frederick Lyons of Norwich |
 Emmanuelle ChriquiMadison | Madison |
 Harry JarvisSir Geoffrey | Sir Geoffrey |
 Ella KenionOld Crone | Old Crone |
 Isabelle FrancaClaire | Claire |
 Mimi GianopulosAlyson | Alyson |
 Jean-Michel Le GalDavid | David |
 Arnold PinnockOfficer Stevens | Officer Stevens |
 Scott Ryan YamamuraEvan | Evan |
 Jayne EastwoodEileen | Eileen |
 Shanice JohnsonPaige | Paige |
| SScott EdgecombeSanta Claus | Santa Claus |
 Kristin ShepherdMrs Claus | Mrs Claus |
| NNeil BabcockJames - Brooke's Ex | James - Brooke's Ex |
| OOlivia GudaniecKaelynn - James' Girlfriend | Kaelynn - James' Girlfriend |
 Alex ArmbrusterYoung Husband at Tree Farm | Young Husband at Tree Farm |
 Brittany Rae RobinsonYoung Wife at Tree Farm | Young Wife at Tree Farm |
 Andrea SeniorChristmas Caroler #2 | Christmas Caroler #2 |
 Hayley FesterygaTeenage Girl | Teenage Girl |
 Jacob SoleyPatrick (uncredited) | Patrick (uncredited) |
 Rob LoweDerek | Derek |
 Kristin DavisKate (archive footage) | Kate (archive footage) |
| CChris HobbsKnight | Knight |
 Simon WebsterReed | Reed |
 Kat GrahamAbby Sutton (archive footage) | Abby Sutton (archive footage) |
 Quincy BrownJosh Barton (archive footage) | Josh Barton (archive footage) |
