Tom Wells is dissatisfied with his lot in life. Wondering aloud whether he'd be happier if things were different, he soon gets his chance to find out. The rest of the story is an extension on the old proverb which begins "Be careful what you wish for."
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Wallace ReidTom Wells | Tom Wells |
 Cleo RidgelySue Wells | Sue Wells |
 Billy JacobsBilly Wells | Billy Wells |
 James NeillJames Peabody | James Peabody |
 Mabel Van BurenMrs. Peabody | Mrs. Peabody |
 Marjorie DawA Fairy | A Fairy |
| BBob FlemingPeabody's Overseer | Peabody's Overseer |