Resolving to achieve professional success without compromising her ethics, Lucy embarks on a ruthless game of one-upmanship against cold and efficient nemesis Joshua, a rivalry that is complicated by her growing attraction to him.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Lucy HaleLucy Hutton | Lucy Hutton |
 Austin StowellJoshua Templeman | Joshua Templeman |
 Corbin BernsenBexley | Bexley |
 Sakina JaffreyHelen | Helen |
 Damon DaunnoDanny | Danny |
 Yasha JacksonJulie | Julie |
 Shona TuckerJeanette | Jeanette |
 Kathryn BoswellMindy | Mindy |
 Sean CullenAnthony Templeman | Anthony Templeman |
 Nance WilliamsonElaine Templeman | Elaine Templeman |
 Brock YurichMack | Mack |
 Robby JohnsonCarl | Carl |
| TTania AsnesAnnabelle | Annabelle |
| NNicholas BaroudiPatrick Templeman | Patrick Templeman |
 David EbertJaf | Jaf |
 Crystal TweedBoard Member | Board Member |
 Kevin CarriganSimon | Simon |
 Katie Lynn JohnsonBrie | Brie |
| RRichard HutchingsPilgrim | Pilgrim |
| DDillon EgyesDaisy | Daisy |