Stock broker Nick Carraway consents to play Cupid for his rich married cousin Daisy Buchanan and her former love, nouveau riche Jay Gatsby.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Toby StephensJay Gatsby | Jay Gatsby |
 Mira SorvinoDaisy Buchanan | Daisy Buchanan |
 Paul RuddNick Carraway | Nick Carraway |
 Martin DonovanTom Buchanan | Tom Buchanan |
 Francie SwiftJordan Baker | Jordan Baker |
 Heather GoldenhershMyrtle Wilson | Myrtle Wilson |
 Matt MalloyKlipspringer | Klipspringer |
 Bill CampWilson | Wilson |
 Richard JutrasOwl Eyes | Owl Eyes |
 Jerry GraysonWolfsheim | Wolfsheim |
 Janine TheriaultCatherine | Catherine |
 Alex BispingBuchanan's Butler | Buchanan's Butler |
 Claudia BessoLucille | Lucille |
 Gillian FerrabeeLil | Lil |
 Tim RozonDandy Man | Dandy Man |
 Tony CalabrettaGatsby's Domestic Thuggish Butler | Gatsby's Domestic Thuggish Butler |
 Andrea SadlerMiss Baedecker | Miss Baedecker |
 Jason ConyersWitness at Accident | Witness at Accident |
 Allen AltmanPoliceman at Accident | Policeman at Accident |
 Ernie JacksonGatsby's Gardener | Gatsby's Gardener |
 Paul HopkinsPoliceman Detective | Policeman Detective |
| MMartin KevanGatsby's Butler | Gatsby's Butler |
| MMegan BroadmanPammy Buchanan | Pammy Buchanan |
| DDean Patrick FlemingPoliceman | Policeman |
| BBurt HarrisHenry C. Gotz | Henry C. Gotz |