When Ally, a popular teen and local celebrity goes missing, her small suburban town erupts in panic.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Tim DalyRonald Gibb | Ronald Gibb |
 Hayden PanettiereAllyson Palmer | Allyson Palmer |
 William SadlerPhil Palmer | Phil Palmer |
 Dan HedayaGabe | Gabe |
 Paula DevicqHolly | Holly |
 Sarah SteeleAmber | Amber |
 John Gallagher Jr.Brett Mullen | Brett Mullen |
 Mark KassenPete Macauley | Pete Macauley |
 Brian Anthony WilsonDetective Dick Moon | Detective Dick Moon |
 Andrew BenatorKari | Kari |
 Maureen MuellerEvelyn Hirsch | Evelyn Hirsch |
| LLisa LyndsTiff | Tiff |
 Rita GardnerMarge Whitman | Marge Whitman |
| DDarrell JamesBartender | Bartender |
 Matthew LawlerUnit Cop 1 | Unit Cop 1 |
| JJoshua FarrellUnit Cop 2 | Unit Cop 2 |
 Kirk LarsenVideo Clerk | Video Clerk |
| SSadler Dolly BakstCaroline | Caroline |
| JJoe JamesVideo Store Patron (uncredited) | Video Store Patron (uncredited) |