Erica vanishes, believed a victim of a serial killer, but emerges at her murder trial 3 years later, having run away to live secretly with her older boyfriend near her mother's home, banned from seeing him.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Lyndsy FonsecaCarrie | Carrie |
 Emma TremblayErica | Erica |
 Kyle ClarkAndrew Jensen | Andrew Jensen |
 Bronwen SmithDetective Richards | Detective Richards |
 Jeremiah OhOfficer Cooper | Officer Cooper |
 Ricardo OrtizLiam | Liam |
 Paul du ToitDaniel Bennett | Daniel Bennett |
 Logan PierceJoey Bennett | Joey Bennett |
 Isa SanchezMartina Martinez | Martina Martinez |
 Maria HerreraCounselor Beth | Counselor Beth |
 Synto D. MisatiRoy | Roy |
 Scott FeeProsecutor | Prosecutor |
| KKraig KrauseField Reporter | Field Reporter |
 Everett AndresJoey Bennett - 15 | Joey Bennett - 15 |
| FForbes AngusJudge | Judge |
| TTanner BornowskyBrody | Brody |
 Ecstasia SandersInterviewer | Interviewer |
 David BeairstoMotel Clerk | Motel Clerk |
 David Allan PearsonJeremy Carver | Jeremy Carver |
 Jason BurkartLange | Lange |
| EElliot ChandlerMan with Dog | Man with Dog |
 Madeleine KeldersProsecutors Assistant | Prosecutors Assistant |