Following the adoption of their longtime babysitter, 16 year old Sophie, Hope begins to suspect her new daughter is hiding a terrible secret that will endanger her family.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Veronika BabinaSophie Tatum | Sophie Tatum |
 Olivia MignoneHope Tatum | Hope Tatum |
 Ryan CallawayJeremiah Tatum | Jeremiah Tatum |
 Clementine BenstockCandace Tatum | Candace Tatum |
 Winnie PenkethmanBrooke Castelli | Brooke Castelli |
 Sasha PearsonKayla Mitchell | Kayla Mitchell |
 Hiram OrtizDr. Simmons | Dr. Simmons |
 Denise Marie WhalenMelissa Castelli | Melissa Castelli |
 Kailee McGuireElla Ingraham | Ella Ingraham |
 Adrian EspinalDexter | Dexter |
| HHannah LemkeBrittany Etters | Brittany Etters |