James Powell, a college senior, falls for Bess Gunther, a sophomore. However, the attractive Bess is deeply in love with F. Scott Fitzgerald, or "Scotty", as she likes to call him. The obsession leads Bess down a road James prefers not to follow. Years later, he wonders whether she's the one that got away.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Alexa DavalosBess Gunther | Bess Gunther |
 Sasha AndreevLibrarian | Librarian |
 Charlie HofheimerJames Powell | James Powell |