 Gene TierneyLucy Muir | Lucy Muir |
 Rex HarrisonCapt. Daniel Gregg | Capt. Daniel Gregg |
 George SandersMiles Fairley | Miles Fairley |
 Edna BestMartha Huggins | Martha Huggins |
 Vanessa BrownAnna Muir as an Adult | Anna Muir as an Adult |
 Anna LeeMrs. Fairley | Mrs. Fairley |
 Robert CooteMr. Coombe | Mr. Coombe |
 Natalie WoodAnna Muir as a Child | Anna Muir as a Child |
 Isobel ElsomAngelica Muir | Angelica Muir |
 Victoria HorneEva Muir | Eva Muir |
 Stuart HolmesMan Ordered Out of Train Compartment by Captain (uncredited) | Man Ordered Out of Train Compartment by Captain (uncredited) |
 Houseley StevensonGardener (uncredited) | Gardener (uncredited) |
 Helen FreemanAuthor Displaced by Lucy (uncredited) | Author Displaced by Lucy (uncredited) |
 Whitford KaneSproule - London Publisher (uncredited) | Sproule - London Publisher (uncredited) |
 Buster SlavenEnquiries at Sproule's (uncredited) | Enquiries at Sproule's (uncredited) |
 Will StantonPorter (uncredited) | Porter (uncredited) |
 William StellingBill - Anna's Fiance (uncredited) | Bill - Anna's Fiance (uncredited) |
| DDavid ThursbyMr. Scroggins (uncredited) | Mr. Scroggins (uncredited) |
| HHeather WildeFairley Maid (uncredited) | Fairley Maid (uncredited) |
