| GGriffin SlivkaThe Bro | The Bro |
| CCarter PeruFrat Exec | Frat Exec |
| EEeshan KumarJudas (Disciple) | Judas (Disciple) |
| CC.J. MorazanPeter (Disciple) | Peter (Disciple) |
| SSage EwingMatthew (Disciple) | Matthew (Disciple) |
| MMolly CorbinMary Magdalene | Mary Magdalene |
| SSean LeinenweberBartholomew (Disciple) | Bartholomew (Disciple) |
| SShelby TeagueFrat Pledge 1 | Frat Pledge 1 |
| SSammy HansonFrat Pledge 2 | Frat Pledge 2 |
| SSamuel TeagueFrat Dude 1 | Frat Dude 1 |
| JJon SanchezFrat Dude 2 | Frat Dude 2 |
| GGary McLeanFrat Pledge 3 | Frat Pledge 3 |
| IIan RodriguezFrat Pledge 4 | Frat Pledge 4 |
| KKennedy JørgensenVillager | Villager |
| MMelissa MorazanVillager 2 | Villager 2 |
| KKee BulkowskiThaddeus (Disciple) | Thaddeus (Disciple) |
| LLewis EckmanJohn (Disciple) | John (Disciple) |
 Dom PiroPhilip (Disciple) | Philip (Disciple) |
| JJaari MorenoRoman Guard | Roman Guard |
| JJeffrey RudolphDisciple Dropout | Disciple Dropout |
| JJaden ParkerVillager 3 | Villager 3 |
| BBella KleinCatcalled Woman | Catcalled Woman |
| JJack BechtelJames the Lesser (Disciple) | James the Lesser (Disciple) |
| MMattie O'HaganJames the Greater (Disciple) | James the Greater (Disciple) |
| JJeremy WinterThomas (Disciple) | Thomas (Disciple) |
| MMax MendozaSimon (Disciple) | Simon (Disciple) |
| JJake LeeAndrew (Disciple) | Andrew (Disciple) |
| MMadison HoGossiping Woman | Gossiping Woman |
| AAbelha SeegmillerInterviewee 2 | Interviewee 2 |
| EEmma McClainInterviewee 3 | Interviewee 3 |
