Chris and RJ, former Mormon missionaries who fell in love seven years ago, are struggling to make their relationship work amid conflicts with their families and their faith. Determined to finally find closure and put the past behind them, the two men set in motion a quest for unconditional love that ultimately leads to the very top of the LDS leadership.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Nick FerrucciRJ Smith | RJ Smith |
 Benjamin FarmerChris Merrill | Chris Merrill |
 Curtis Edward JacksonRyan Woodrow | Ryan Woodrow |
 Bruce JenningsNoah Merrill | Noah Merrill |
 Harold PhillipsTom Smith | Tom Smith |
| RRebecca KarpovskySheris Hurwitz | Sheris Hurwitz |
| MMalaya GarzaKaylee Marrill | Kaylee Marrill |
| AAlexandra SpadoniAdina Hurwitz | Adina Hurwitz |
 Darrell SalkPresident Thomas | President Thomas |
| AAndrew BrayGreg Merrill | Greg Merrill |
 Benji SchwimmerOfficiant | Officiant |
| GGarland LyonsElder Pierce | Elder Pierce |
 Martin Bannon BeaudetBudtender | Budtender |
| AAudrey WalkerBrenda Smith | Brenda Smith |
| RRandy DraperElder Peterson | Elder Peterson |
| KKacey MannyMary Anne Buell | Mary Anne Buell |
| SStephanie LeppertChelsea Merrill | Chelsea Merrill |
| JJulie Marie HowardRoseanne Young | Roseanne Young |
| JJohnny BuellMary Anne's Husband | Mary Anne's Husband |
| EEleanor Pizza PuellMary Anne's Daughter | Mary Anne's Daughter |