Based on the book by Caroline B. Cooney, a girl happens to look down at a milk carton one day and she sees herself on the back! Could her parents really have kidnapped her?
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Kellie MartinJennifer Sands | Jennifer Sands |
 Sharon LawrenceSada Sands | Sada Sands |
 Edward HerrmannFrank Jessmon | Frank Jessmon |
 Richard MasurJonathan Sands | Jonathan Sands |
 Johnny GreenReeve Shields | Reeve Shields |
 Jill ClayburghMiranda Jessmon | Miranda Jessmon |
| KKristoffer Ryan WintersStephen Sands | Stephen Sands |
| CCaroline PerreyclearJodie Sands | Jodie Sands |
 Joanna CantonSarah-Charlotte | Sarah-Charlotte |
 Lorri LindbergMrs. Shields | Mrs. Shields |
| LLeslie HallAdair | Adair |
| KKawan RojanatavornPeter | Peter |
| PPaul DowJason | Jason |
| EEllen SeltzLizzie Shields | Lizzie Shields |
 Richard K. OlsenL. McDonnell | L. McDonnell |
 David DwyerBrian Mollison | Brian Mollison |
| LLee FreemanCatherine Webster | Catherine Webster |