On a snowy Christmas Eve, Santa Claus is kidnapped and held for ransom. A young elf goes on a mission to find a magic key that will help her free Santa Claus. Sequel to the special "The Elf Who Saved Christmas."
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
| WWendy J. CookeToby | Toby |
| HHarry FrazierSanta Claus | Santa Claus |
| DDink O'NealBuzzard Brother #1 | Buzzard Brother #1 |
 Roger PerryHead Elf | Head Elf |
| FF. Thom SpadaroHead Elf | Head Elf |
| LLara TeeterBuzzard Brother #2 | Buzzard Brother #2 |
| FF. Thom SpadaroDitty | Ditty |
| LLee WilsonTrixie | Trixie |
 Jo Anne WorleyMrs. Buzzard | Mrs. Buzzard |
 Barry LivingstonHoot | Hoot |