On September 4, 2002 two women were found dead inside the Dolly Madison bakery in Great Bend Kansas. Twenty years after the murders, a filmmaker finds that there might be hidden reasons as to why it has remained unsolved all these years.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
| AAmy WangbergSelf | Self |
| DDean AkingsSelf | Self |
| CConnie CarrSelf | Self |
| DDale E. HoggSelf | Self |
| RReggie KernSelf | Self |
| KKathye PhelpsSelf | Self |
| KKaren SunderlandSelf | Self |
| DDesiree WerthSelf | Self |
| BBrian J. BellinderSelf | Self |
| NNicholas ElliottKiller (Re-enactments) | Killer (Re-enactments) |
| MMarty KeenanSelf | Self |
| MMarcus MullKiller (Re-enactments) | Killer (Re-enactments) |
| HHeather Davis SmithSelf | Self |
| AAaron MullSelf | Self |
| CCarol WilliamsSelf | Self |