Two brothers and their wives meet up at a haute-cuisine restaurant to discuss what to do about a horrific crime that their sons committed together. As the quartet debate their options, the conversation reopens old wounds between the siblings.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Richard GereStan Lohman | Stan Lohman |
 Laura LinneyClaire Lohman | Claire Lohman |
 Steve CooganPaul Lohman | Paul Lohman |
 Rebecca HallKatelyn Lohman | Katelyn Lohman |
 Chloë SevignyBarbara Lohman | Barbara Lohman |
 Michael ChernusDylan Heinz | Dylan Heinz |
 Seamus Davey-FitzpatrickRick Lohman | Rick Lohman |
 Charlie PlummerMichael Lohman | Michael Lohman |
 Adepero OduyeNina | Nina |
 Dominic ColónRafael | Rafael |
 Joel BissonnetteAntonio | Antonio |
 Miles J. HarveyBeau Lohman | Beau Lohman |
| EEmma R. MuddVal Lohman | Val Lohman |
 Laura HajekAnna | Anna |
 Robert G. McKayPrincipal Crane | Principal Crane |
 Onika DayMoriah | Moriah |
| GGeorge AloiDan | Dan |
| JJesse Dean PetersonEight-Year-Old Michael Lohman | Eight-Year-Old Michael Lohman |
| BBenjamin SnyderEight-Year-Old Rick Lohman | Eight-Year-Old Rick Lohman |
 Justin L. WilsonMusician | Musician |
| JJohn MitchellConstruction Worker | Construction Worker |
| MMichael MardoParty Goer | Party Goer |
| MMichael MardoFrat Party Goer | Frat Party Goer |
| TTaylor Rae AlmonteThe Hostess | The Hostess |