| EErnest KearneyRudy Barnett | Rudy Barnett |
| DDamon EvansNat Boyle | Nat Boyle |
 Sarah CarsonRita | Rita |
 Debra LambErica Barnett | Erica Barnett |
| DDouglas MacphersonTony Whitney | Tony Whitney |
 Dani ScottCheryl Whitney | Cheryl Whitney |
| RRachael OlsemLouisa Pussmunch | Louisa Pussmunch |
 John McCaffertyReggie Regalia | Reggie Regalia |
 G. Larry ButlerFather Dickinson | Father Dickinson |
| MMatthew DuboisPaster Rod Fitzhugh | Paster Rod Fitzhugh |
| IIvy VotolatoLucy Lickenbush | Lucy Lickenbush |
| HHank GroverKensington | Kensington |
| DDaniel KrauseEvangelical Stage Manager | Evangelical Stage Manager |
 Michael GaglioFirst Producer | First Producer |
 Charley RossmanMax Tension | Max Tension |
| PPaul BunnellMax Tension's Yes Man | Max Tension's Yes Man |
| BBraddon MendelsonJeff Specter | Jeff Specter |
| TTed NichelsonYoung Priest at Funeral | Young Priest at Funeral |
| GGiulia Da PianSexy Waitress | Sexy Waitress |
| MMark PirroUpset Husband in Ad | Upset Husband in Ad |
 Joycelyne LewAsian Wife in Ad | Asian Wife in Ad |
| YY.K. ChanAsian Husband in Ad | Asian Husband in Ad |
 Azize ErimBobbi McBlythe | Bobbi McBlythe |
| MMark SawickiDrunk Man at Bar | Drunk Man at Bar |
| BBrandon WainwrightBlind Man at Bar | Blind Man at Bar |
| RRobyn BlytheGloria Sternvirgin | Gloria Sternvirgin |
