 Mackenzie ShirillaSelf | Self |
| TTim TroupSelf - Assistant Prosecutor | Self - Assistant Prosecutor |
| RRosie GrahamSelf - Friend | Self - Friend |
| BBubba TurnerSelf - Friend | Self - Friend |
| FFaythe WalshSelf - Childhood Friend | Self - Childhood Friend |
| SSteve ShirillaSelf - Mackenzie's Father | Self - Mackenzie's Father |
| NNatalie ShirillaSelf - Mackenzie's Mother | Self - Mackenzie's Mother |
| FFrank RussoSelf - Dominic's Father | Self - Dominic's Father |
| CChristy RussoSelf - Dominic's Mother | Self - Dominic's Mother |
| AAngelo RussoSelf - Dominic's Brother | Self - Dominic's Brother |
| CChristine RussoSelf - Dominic's Sister | Self - Dominic's Sister |
| DDavyne FlanaganSelf - Davion's Sister | Self - Davion's Sister |
| SScott FlanaganSelf - Davion's Father | Self - Davion's Father |
| JJaime FlanaganSelf - Davion's Mother | Self - Davion's Mother |
| DDominic RussoSelf (archive footage) | Self (archive footage) |
| DDavion FlanaganSelf (archive footage) | Self (archive footage) |
| EElliot RawsonSelf - Ohio State Highway Patrol | Self - Ohio State Highway Patrol |
| RRyan FoxSelf - Ohio State Highway Patrol | Self - Ohio State Highway Patrol |
| JJames McDonnellSelf - Mackenzie Shirilla's Lawyer | Self - Mackenzie Shirilla's Lawyer |
| NNancy M. RussoSelf - Judge | Self - Judge |
| CChristopher MartinSelf - Christy Russo's Friend | Self - Christy Russo's Friend |
