While Judge Hardy handles a couple's divorce, Andy takes a shine to their shy daughter.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Lewis StoneJudge Hardy | Judge Hardy |
 Mickey RooneyAndy Hardy | Andy Hardy |
 Cecilia ParkerMarian Hardy | Marian Hardy |
 Fay HoldenEmily Hardy | Emily Hardy |
 Ann RutherfordPolly Benedict | Polly Benedict |
 Sara HadenMilly Forrest | Milly Forrest |
 Donna ReedMelodie Nesbit | Melodie Nesbit |
 William LundiganJeff Willis | Jeff Willis |
| SSteve CornellStewart Dwight | Stewart Dwight |
 Frieda InescortOlivia Nesbit | Olivia Nesbit |
 Harvey StephensRoderick O. Nesbit | Roderick O. Nesbit |
| BBetty WellsSusie | Susie |
 Joseph CrehanPeter Dugan | Peter Dugan |
 George P. BreakstonBeezy | Beezy |
 Todd KarnsHarry Land | Harry Land |
 Tim RyanFarrell (uncredited) | Farrell (uncredited) |