Sherlock Holmes is merely a framing device for the real story: The Treasure of Alpheus T. Winterborn. A small-town boy accidentally uncovers a list of mystifying clues to a hidden treasure left by the late Alpheus T. Winterborn, the town's richest citizen.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
| DDotty GoodmanMiss Eells | Miss Eells |
| KKeith MitchellAnthony Monday | Anthony Monday |
| KKeith McConnellSherlock Holmes | Sherlock Holmes |
 Laurie MainDr. Watson | Dr. Watson |
 Louis GussMr. Loomis | Mr. Loomis |
| AArt KassulNot listed | Not listed |
| HHale PorterNot listed | Not listed |
 Stanley GroverNot listed | Not listed |
 Frank DentNot listed | Not listed |
| CClaire MalisMrs. Ginny Monday | Mrs. Ginny Monday |