The Mitchell brothers compete to see who can create the best Christmas House.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Robert BuckleyMike Mitchell | Mike Mitchell |
 Ana AyoraAndi Cruz | Andi Cruz |
 Jonathan BennettBrandon Mitchell | Brandon Mitchell |
 Brad HarderJake | Jake |
 Treat WilliamsBill Mitchell | Bill Mitchell |
 Sharon LawrencePhylis Mitchell | Phylis Mitchell |
 Michelle HarrisonKathleen | Kathleen |
 Matthew James DowdenZane | Zane |
 Teryl RotheryMacie Stevens | Macie Stevens |
 Chris GauthierMarvelous Jim | Marvelous Jim |
 Robyn DriscollJudge | Judge |
| AAlycia EscovalUsher | Usher |