A socially awkward man finds himself stuck in a holiday love triangle and learns that doing the right thing can lead to something real.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
| SSeth O'HerinNot listed | Not listed |
| HHope HarvardMia Barrett | Mia Barrett |
| JJohn AllenAllen Bontrager | Allen Bontrager |
 Stephen FisherJeff Wilkins | Jeff Wilkins |
| MMarguerite HainesSophia Wilkins | Sophia Wilkins |
| TTroy FiteMark Wilkins | Mark Wilkins |