Exes Lara and Ben compete in a Christmas contest to win money for the charity of their choosing. The city watches them battle and choose what is more important, victory or love.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Candace Cameron BureLara | Lara |
 John BrothertonBen | Ben |
 Barbara NivenDonna | Donna |
 BJ HarrisonMartha | Martha |
 Jennifer HigginBernie | Bernie |
 Doron BellMarty | Marty |
 Keenan TraceyChuck | Chuck |
 Matteus LunotJayce | Jayce |
 Daxton GujralLiam | Liam |
| KKingston GomesEllis | Ellis |
 Nevin BurkholderBill | Bill |
| LLisa HuynhZoey | Zoey |
 Advah SoudackMia | Mia |
 Barbara WallaceBeth | Beth |
| TTavia CerviLindsay | Lindsay |
 Kate WhiddingtonYoung Lara | Young Lara |