Two busy strangers meet when they help an elderly woman find her lost Christmas savings. Thanks to fate and Christmas magic, they also find something they were both missing: true love.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Elizabeth MitchellOlivia | Olivia |
 Cameron MathisonEdward | Edward |
 Zoe FishMaeryn | Maeryn |
| JJenny PudavickBeth | Beth |
| EEllliott LedlowConner | Conner |
 Adam HurtigMatt | Matt |
 Rachael McLarenCarrie | Carrie |
 Sheila McCarthyMiss Maggie | Miss Maggie |
 Gabrielle RoseGertrude | Gertrude |
 Kate TrotterBarb | Barb |
 Ernie PittsGreg | Greg |
 Stephanie SyLynn | Lynn |
 Paul EssiembreMayor Parker | Mayor Parker |
| AAaron MerkleCabbie | Cabbie |
| DDaria PuttaertCustomer | Customer |
| AAdrian McCleanVendor | Vendor |
 Verity MarksTeenage Clerk | Teenage Clerk |
| TTom KeenanGuy in Cab | Guy in Cab |
| AAyla NguyenSnowflake #1 | Snowflake #1 |
| MMeredith BuhlerSnowflake #2 | Snowflake #2 |
| GGenevieve BouchardSnowflake #3 | Snowflake #3 |
| GGabrielle TherrienSnowflake #4 | Snowflake #4 |
| LLacey MathewSnowflake #5 | Snowflake #5 |
| LLindsay NelkoChoreographer | Choreographer |
 Tom YoungSanta | Santa |