 Vincent PriceJames Addison Reavis | James Addison Reavis |
 Ellen DrewSofia de Peralta-Reavis | Sofia de Peralta-Reavis |
 Vladimir SokoloffPepito Alvarez | Pepito Alvarez |
 Beulah BondiLoma Morales | Loma Morales |
 Reed HadleyJohn Griff | John Griff |
 Robert BarratJudge Adams | Judge Adams |
| RRobin ShortTom Lansing | Tom Lansing |
| KKaren KesterSofia as a child | Sofia as a child |
 Margia DeanMarquesa de Santella | Marquesa de Santella |
 Jonathan HaleGovernor | Governor |
 I. Stanford JolleyMr. Richardson | Mr. Richardson |
| TTina PineRita | Rita |
 Angelo RossittoAngie -- Gypsy | Angie -- Gypsy |
 Edward KeaneSurveyor General Miller | Surveyor General Miller |
 Barbara WoodellMrs. Carrie Lansing | Mrs. Carrie Lansing |
 Fred Kohler Jr.Demmings | Demmings |
 Tristram CoffinMcCleary | McCleary |
 Gene RothFather Guardian | Father Guardian |
| EEd EastHank | Hank |
| JJoseph J. GreeneMr. Gunther | Mr. Gunther |
| AAbdullah AbbasIndian (uncredited) | Indian (uncredited) |
| WWalter BaconTownsman (uncredited) | Townsman (uncredited) |
| RRay BeltramTownsman (uncredited) | Townsman (uncredited) |
| EEumenio BlancoGypsy (uncredited) | Gypsy (uncredited) |
| PPhil BloomTownsman (uncredited) | Townsman (uncredited) |
| NNick BorganiGypsy (uncredited) | Gypsy (uncredited) |
| BBuck BuckoVigilante (uncredited) | Vigilante (uncredited) |
| RRoy BuckoTownsman (uncredited) | Townsman (uncredited) |
 Wheaton ChambersBrother Gregory (uncredited) | Brother Gregory (uncredited) |
 Noble 'Kid' ChissellTownsman (uncredited) | Townsman (uncredited) |
