The Halloween ban is now lifted in Helen's Valley, and the sorority girls of Gamma Tau Psi place Michelle in charge of their annual haunted house. Unfortunately for Michelle some uninvited trick or treaters from her past come knocking.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Lexi DrippsMichelle Fairchild | Michelle Fairchild |
 Sable GriedelHeather | Heather |
 Mitchell MusolinoSam Daniels | Sam Daniels |
 Lloyd KaufmanTown Mayor | Town Mayor |
 Linnea QuigleySara Barnhart | Sara Barnhart |
 Doug BradleyWalter Daniels | Walter Daniels |
 Ari LehmanDr. Rock | Dr. Rock |
 John BloomDrive-In Joe | Drive-In Joe |
 Diana PrinceDottie | Dottie |
 Chad BrunsCharlie | Charlie |
 Will StoutJosh Harper | Josh Harper |
 Jordan BeltzLisa | Lisa |
 Drew MarvickTroop Leader Plums | Troop Leader Plums |
 Kaylee WilliamsBrittany | Brittany |
 Julie Anne PrescottJessica | Jessica |
 Alyss WinklerTracy | Tracy |
| JJerry LarewKirk | Kirk |
| BBrooklyn EwingTori | Tori |
 Brian PapandreaFrank | Frank |
| WWayne W. JohnsonWyatt Thomas | Wyatt Thomas |
| BBen DietelsBrett | Brett |
| JJohn Hale IIIFarmer Barry | Farmer Barry |
| MMike LombardoVideo Store Customer #1 | Video Store Customer #1 |
| DDaniel Alan KielySheriff Cooper | Sheriff Cooper |
| JJames WeldonStan Daniels | Stan Daniels |