Four best friends reconnect with the goal of attending a legendary Halloween party called "The Annual". The only catch? It happened in 2004.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Griffin CorkCameron | Cameron |
| CCaitlin DavidsonStacy | Stacy |
| MMichael Benjamin WelshPaul | Paul |
 Erin MickJane | Jane |
 M.J. KehlerSarah (as Shannon Kehler) | Sarah (as Shannon Kehler) |
| LLukas KowalkoDoug | Doug |
| HHannah AbbeyJessica | Jessica |
| JJocko GartonPatrick | Patrick |
| BBradley SpurgeBrad | Brad |
 Jonathan DrewTim | Tim |