The true story of the Long Island teen who shoots and wounds the wife of a man she called her lover.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Drew BarrymoreAmy Fisher | Amy Fisher |
 Tony DenisonJoey Buttafuoco | Joey Buttafuoco |
 Harley Jane KozakAmy Pagnozzi | Amy Pagnozzi |
 Tom MasonEric Naiburg | Eric Naiburg |
 Laurie PatonMary Jo Buttafuoco | Mary Jo Buttafuoco |
 Ken PogueElliot Fisher | Elliot Fisher |
 Linda DarlowRoseann Fisher | Roseann Fisher |
 Gabe KhouthTim Russo | Tim Russo |
 Garry DaveyDetective | Detective |
 Dwight McFeeDaniel Severin | Daniel Severin |
 Philip GrangerWilliams | Williams |
| WWalter MarshJudge Marvin Goodman | Judge Marvin Goodman |
| TTerry KingFred Klein | Fred Klein |
 Charles SiegelMarvyn Kornberg | Marvyn Kornberg |
| LLindsay BourneEd Grilli | Ed Grilli |
| MMichael GabrielPeter Guagenti | Peter Guagenti |
 Philip Maurice HayesPaul Makely | Paul Makely |
 Kim KondrashoffJohn | John |
 Terry David MulliganRafael Aramovitz | Rafael Aramovitz |
 Robin MossleyDoctor | Doctor |