What begins as a documentary following the final tour of a dying magician - "The Amazing Johnathan" - becomes an unexpected and increasingly bizarre journey as the filmmaker struggles to separate truth from illusion.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
| TThe Amazing JohnathanSelf | Self |
 Penn JilletteSelf | Self |
| CCriss AngelSelf | Self |
 Max MavenSelf | Self |
 'Weird Al' YankovicSelf | Self |
 Eric AndréSelf | Self |
 Judy GoldSelf | Self |
 Carrot TopSelf | Self |
| AAnastasia SynnSelf | Self |
| MMarvin RoySelf | Self |
| DDoreen SzelesSelf | Self |
| JJon MugarSelf | Self |
| CChad S. TaylorSelf | Self |
| DDoug BermanSelf | Self |
| WWendy CarraherSelf | Self |
 Keith DallasSelf | Self |
 Simon ChinnSelf | Self |
 Ben BermanSelf | Self |