| SSuzanne SadlerMother (segment "Reunion") | Mother (segment "Reunion") |
 Rick Montgomery Jr.Doctor (segment "Reunion") (as Rick Montgomery) | Doctor (segment "Reunion") (as Rick Montgomery) |
 Miranda GrussMiranda (segment "Reunion") | Miranda (segment "Reunion") |
 Rebecca GrussRebecca (segment "Reunion") | Rebecca (segment "Reunion") |
| CCorre GriffithButler (segment "Reunion") | Butler (segment "Reunion") |
| ZZachary James AkersDriver (segment "Reunion") | Driver (segment "Reunion") |
| CCalli RammelSnake Girl / Crowd (segment "Reunion") | Snake Girl / Crowd (segment "Reunion") |
| JJesse LeChokDog Boy (segment "Reunion") | Dog Boy (segment "Reunion") |
| EEbony BlackMole Girl (segment "Reunion") | Mole Girl (segment "Reunion") |
| DDakota CorwinHuman Worm (segment "Reunion") | Human Worm (segment "Reunion") |
| MMatthew ShanksRubber Man / Crowd (segment "Reunion") | Rubber Man / Crowd (segment "Reunion") |
| RRyan NogyJenny (segment "Billy") | Jenny (segment "Billy") |
| RRichard BillockFather (segment "Billy") | Father (segment "Billy") |
| AAlyssa HerronMother (segment "Billy") | Mother (segment "Billy") |
| CCassandra KammererQueen / Fairy (segment "The Companion") | Queen / Fairy (segment "The Companion") |
 Andrew Zibritosky(segment "The Devil's Halo") | (segment "The Devil's Halo") |
| AAmila Niksić(segment "The Devil's Halo") | (segment "The Devil's Halo") |
| NNick Staso(segment "The Devil's Halo") | (segment "The Devil's Halo") |
| BBrandon Mangin(segment "The Devil's Halo") | (segment "The Devil's Halo") |
| RRafeal VasquezCrowd (segment "Reunion") | Crowd (segment "Reunion") |
| CCody ShafferCrowd (segment "Reunion") | Crowd (segment "Reunion") |
| DDavid GernhardtCrowd (segment "Reunion") | Crowd (segment "Reunion") |
| AAmanda LovelessCrowd (segment "Reunion") | Crowd (segment "Reunion") |
| DDreu MorelandCrowd (segment "Reunion") | Crowd (segment "Reunion") |
| SStephen DixonCrowd (segment "Reunion") | Crowd (segment "Reunion") |
| NNicholas CarringtonCrowd (segment "Reunion") | Crowd (segment "Reunion") |
| JJason DelzellCrowd (segment "Reunion") | Crowd (segment "Reunion") |