 Jennifer RunyonMelanie (segment "Epidemic") | Melanie (segment "Epidemic") |
 Lynn LowrySusan McKay (segment "By Proxy") | Susan McKay (segment "By Proxy") |
 Felissa RoseWitch (segment "Epidemic") | Witch (segment "Epidemic") |
 Helene UdySonya Hamilton (segment "Epidemic") | Sonya Hamilton (segment "Epidemic") |
 Laurene LandonMiss Tate (segment "Radical Video") | Miss Tate (segment "Radical Video") |
 Ari LehmanEdmond Blackburn (segment "Epidemic") | Edmond Blackburn (segment "Epidemic") |
 Jonathan TierstenThe Sledgehammer (segment "Radical Video") | The Sledgehammer (segment "Radical Video") |
 Christopher ShowermanThe Driver (wraparound story) | The Driver (wraparound story) |
 Yan BirchSatan | Satan |
 Ashley ParkAlisha Harding (segment "Radical Video") | Alisha Harding (segment "Radical Video") |
 Heath C. HeinePolice Officer (segment "By Proxy") | Police Officer (segment "By Proxy") |
| JJosh OutzenGrocery Delivery Guy (segment "By Proxy") | Grocery Delivery Guy (segment "By Proxy") |
| HHilarie GraceAnnoyed Customer in Line 4 (segment "Radical Video") | Annoyed Customer in Line 4 (segment "Radical Video") |
| VVivienne BersinNostalgic Video Store Customer (segment "Radical Video") | Nostalgic Video Store Customer (segment "Radical Video") |
| MMark CanjarCoroner (segment "Radical Video") | Coroner (segment "Radical Video") |
| AAlec YbarraSoccer Kid (segment "By Proxy") | Soccer Kid (segment "By Proxy") |
| AAeon CruzNostalgic Video Store Customer (segment "Radical Video") | Nostalgic Video Store Customer (segment "Radical Video") |
| JJosh FeldmanSoccer Kid (segment "By Proxy") | Soccer Kid (segment "By Proxy") |
| BBekah JungGeisha Girl (segment "Epidemic") | Geisha Girl (segment "Epidemic") |
 Alaina GarlandVickie Summers (segment "Radical Video") | Vickie Summers (segment "Radical Video") |
| AAllie EscaffiLFGR News Reporter Vera Drake (segment "Radical Video") | LFGR News Reporter Vera Drake (segment "Radical Video") |
| OOlivia Crist16th Century Villager (segment "Epidemic") | 16th Century Villager (segment "Epidemic") |
| JJewel CavazosSamantha McKenny (segment "Radical Video") | Samantha McKenny (segment "Radical Video") |
| PPam RenallKristen / Annoyed Customer in Line 2 | Kristen / Annoyed Customer in Line 2 |
| MMadeleine OursPossessed Fiancée (segment "Epidemic") | Possessed Fiancée (segment "Epidemic") |
| KKaren E. ThomasDr. Pamela Myers (segment "By Proxy") | Dr. Pamela Myers (segment "By Proxy") |
| BBailey SorrelMaya (wraparound story) | Maya (wraparound story) |
| EElla MadisonSoccer Kid (segment "By Proxy") | Soccer Kid (segment "By Proxy") |
| BBen HilzerBlaine Moore (segment "Radical Video") | Blaine Moore (segment "Radical Video") |
 Kevin Sean RyanChurch Show Host (segment "Epidemic") | Church Show Host (segment "Epidemic") |
