 Shane Ryan-ReidBrandon | Brandon |
 Mindy RobinsonGrace The Reporter | Grace The Reporter |
 Dywayne ThomasJohn Murphy | John Murphy |
 Sabrina CulverStacy Miller | Stacy Miller |
| IIce CoolChad | Chad |
 Ken HolmesMiguel 'Snakeskin' Perez | Miguel 'Snakeskin' Perez |
 Cris CochraneSamael 'Sam' Dubhan | Samael 'Sam' Dubhan |
| LLeah CoonceKaren | Karen |
| JJosh OutzenTed Bundy Admirer | Ted Bundy Admirer |
 Gary Lee VincentAgent Walker | Agent Walker |
 Mark ValerianoNot listed | Not listed |
| MMichael LakeJared Oakley | Jared Oakley |
| MMarc HocklNot listed | Not listed |
 Sophia CacciolaKelly Thompson (segment: Cable 54 News - Why Do Killers Kill?) | Kelly Thompson (segment: Cable 54 News - Why Do Killers Kill?) |
 Brandi AguilarPiper Lopez | Piper Lopez |
| KKelley Wilson RobinsonRoxie | Roxie |
 Glenn BerggoetzBill Carl | Bill Carl |
| EEmily McKinley HillNot listed | Not listed |
 Jason ImpeyOfficer Joe Newton | Officer Joe Newton |
 Acadia ColanSerena | Serena |
 Richard ChandlerBiker | Biker |
| TTony NewtonNot listed | Not listed |
| NNavah RaphaelParker Rhodes | Parker Rhodes |
| DDelaney ValleseVictim's Sister | Victim's Sister |
| SSteven PerilloInterviewee | Interviewee |
| RRosann FerrierJan Parsons - Criminal Psychology | Jan Parsons - Criminal Psychology |
| HHunter OttoHunter Schmidt | Hunter Schmidt |
 Bryden Elliott DiGennaroVictim's Friend | Victim's Friend |
 Derrick GilbertYoung kid | Young kid |
| GGant MontgomeryOfficer Thompson | Officer Thompson |
