With Valentine's Day coming up, Alice decides to go on a dating app where she finds the seemingly perfect match. She soon realizes that her "Valentine" is an imposter who stole the identity of his former roommate in order to insert himself into her life.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Jamie BernadetteAlice | Alice |
 Eric RobertsEd Stein | Ed Stein |
 Michael ParéBill | Bill |
 Tracy NelsonSusie | Susie |
 Tom SandovalJason | Jason |
 Jackée HarryDetective Graham | Detective Graham |
 Caryn RichmanDr. Taylor | Dr. Taylor |
 Daniel JooDetective Ross | Detective Ross |
 Philip McElroyDetective Hamm | Detective Hamm |
 Matthew PohlkampChris | Chris |
 Jasmine AivaliotisPauline | Pauline |
 Brian NolanLouis | Louis |
 Alana WalkerJane | Jane |
 Peter Daniel AdamsJake | Jake |
 Grisselle EscottoMercedes | Mercedes |