 Vincent PriceLocke / Fortunato / Valdemar / Narrator | Locke / Fortunato / Valdemar / Narrator |
 Peter LorreMontresor ("The Black Cat") | Montresor ("The Black Cat") |
 Basil RathboneCarmichael ("The Case of M. Valdemar") | Carmichael ("The Case of M. Valdemar") |
 Debra PagetHelene ("The Case of M. Valdemar") | Helene ("The Case of M. Valdemar") |
 Maggie PierceLenora ("Morella") | Lenora ("Morella") |
 Joyce JamesonAnnabel ("The Black Cat") | Annabel ("The Black Cat") |
| LLeona GageMorella ("Morella") | Morella ("Morella") |
 David FrankhamDr. James ("The Case of M. Valdemar") | Dr. James ("The Case of M. Valdemar") |
 Lennie WeinribPoliceman ("The Black Cat") | Policeman ("The Black Cat") |
 Wally CampoBarman Wilkins ("The Black Cat") | Barman Wilkins ("The Black Cat") |
| AAlan DeWittChairman of Wine Society ("The Black Cat") | Chairman of Wine Society ("The Black Cat") |
 John HackettPoliceman ("The Black Cat") | Policeman ("The Black Cat") |
 Edmund CobbDriver ("Morella") | Driver ("Morella") |
| SScott BrownServant ("The Case of M. Valdemar") | Servant ("The Case of M. Valdemar") |
| BBenjie BancroftWine Society Member ("The Black Cat") (uncredited) | Wine Society Member ("The Black Cat") (uncredited) |
| PPaul BradleyWine Society Member ("The Black Cat") (uncredited) | Wine Society Member ("The Black Cat") (uncredited) |
| KKenneth GibsonWine Society Member ("The Black Cat") (uncredited) | Wine Society Member ("The Black Cat") (uncredited) |
 Kenner G. KempWine Society Member ("The Black Cat") (uncredited) | Wine Society Member ("The Black Cat") (uncredited) |
 Jack KennyTavern Patron ("The Black Cat") (uncredited) | Tavern Patron ("The Black Cat") (uncredited) |
 Cosmo SardoWine Society Member ("The Black Cat") (uncredited) | Wine Society Member ("The Black Cat") (uncredited) |
 Jack TornekWine Society Member ("The Black Cat") (uncredited) | Wine Society Member ("The Black Cat") (uncredited) |
