Unrequited love gets a second chance when two women reunite several years after attending convent school together.
| Actor | Role |
|---|---|
 Lisa PepperNicole | Nicole |
| KKari ReynoldsGrace | Grace |
| AAshley ShubertGrace at 5 | Grace at 5 |
| CCatherine RawlsNicole at 5 | Nicole at 5 |
 Chelsea AldenGrace at 10 | Grace at 10 |
| JJustine SpragueNicole at 10 | Nicole at 10 |
 Zephyr GozaMichael Gavtier | Michael Gavtier |
| EElaina McBroomSister Damian | Sister Damian |
| GGlenda ChismSister Paula | Sister Paula |
| KKelly HillSister Maria | Sister Maria |
 Emile HirschBrad | Brad |
 David KoplanJason | Jason |
| TTish ShaniaMonique | Monique |
| CChris SolariSmoking Boy | Smoking Boy |
| BBreezy Twilight GloverBaby Grace | Baby Grace |