 Heather DonahueHeather Donahue | Heather Donahue |
 Joshua LeonardJosh Leonard | Josh Leonard |
 Michael C. WilliamsMichael Williams | Michael Williams |
| FFrank PastorRustin Parr | Rustin Parr |
| JJoe Nagy11 News anchor | 11 News anchor |
| MMinette Marcial6 News anchor | 6 News anchor |
| KKeith WhittakerNewschannel 6 reporter | Newschannel 6 reporter |
| BBuck BuchananPrivate investigator | Private investigator |
| CCharlie CarlsonCharles Moorhouse, professor of folklore | Charles Moorhouse, professor of folklore |
| LLucan JohnsonGuest on Mystic Occurences | Guest on Mystic Occurences |
| BBill DreggorsBill Barnes, Burkittsville historian | Bill Barnes, Burkittsville historian |
| EElaine ShynerSister of Rustin Parr victim | Sister of Rustin Parr victim |
| RRonald CravensRonald Cravens, Burkittsville sheriff | Ronald Cravens, Burkittsville sheriff |
| MMichael HooverMichael DeCoto, film professor | Michael DeCoto, film professor |
| TTom WilliamsTom Williams, brother of Michael Williams | Tom Williams, brother of Michael Williams |
| DDavid JonesDavid Mercer, professor of anthropology | David Mercer, professor of anthropology |
| MMark MasonMember of Burkittsville Volunteer Fire Department | Member of Burkittsville Volunteer Fire Department |
| BBud MichelsMember of Burkittsville Volunteer Fire Department | Member of Burkittsville Volunteer Fire Department |
 Daniel MyrickInterviewer (voice) | Interviewer (voice) |
 Eduardo SánchezInterviewer (voice) | Interviewer (voice) |
